
One of my clients was recently preparing for a skip-level meeting with their C-suite leader. The invitation landed in their inbox with no context or supporting details. In a highly political and complex environment, the hardest part was not deciding what to say. It was working out why the meeting was happening and what was expected of them.
That uncertainty sits at the heart of many skip-level meetings.
Depending on where you sit, the same invitation can look like an opportunity, an assessment, a chance to connect or an unwelcome intrusion. And because the conversation affects three relationships (i.e. the employee, their manager and the senior leader), each may arrive with very different assumptions about what it is for.
Done well, skip-level meetings strengthen connection, support development and give senior leaders a clearer view of what is happening across the organisation.
In contrast, when done poorly, they can create suspicion, undermine the manager, expose the employee to unnecessary risk, and establish a shadow reporting line.
The difference comes down to three things: purpose, preparation and protection.
Why the Conversation Matters
Relationships above your immediate reporting line matter to both your career and your ability to do your work.
Research involving 448 employees found that professional networks supported career success by providing access to information, resources and career sponsorship. Contacts at higher organisational levels were particularly relevant to sponsorship.1
A skip-level meeting does not guarantee advocacy. It does, however, give a senior leader the opportunity to understand your contribution in a broader context, offer insights you may not otherwise receive and connect you to possibilities beyond your immediate line of sight.
Skip-level conversations can also help information move in both directions. Employees gain broader context about strategy and decisions, while senior leaders gain a clearer understanding of how those decisions are being experienced.
In busy, complex, and increasingly hybrid workplaces, these connections may not happen naturally, so they need to be created deliberately.
However, simply scheduling a skip-level meeting is not enough.
Research by Professors James Detert and Linda Treviño found that employees do not judge whether it is safe to speak up solely by watching their immediate manager. They also take their cues from leaders further up the organisation.
In 89 interviews, employees referred to leaders two to five levels above them almost as often as they referred to their direct supervisor when explaining why raising concerns, questioning decisions or offering a different view felt risky or pointless.²
The implication is important. Senior leaders shape whether employees believe candour will be welcomed, ignored or punished, even when they have little direct contact with them. A skip-level conversation is therefore not just an exchange of information. It also signals how the organisation responds when someone speaks honestly.
The Senior Leader’s Preparation
The senior leader carries particular responsibility for setting the conversation up well. They hold the most organisational power, usually initiated the meeting and are best placed to remove uncertainty about why it is happening.
Before the conversation
Be clear about the purpose
Skip-level meetings can come with very different expectations.
The senior leader may genuinely want to build connection, understand what is happening closer to the work or identify emerging talent. They may also be holding the meeting because HR has asked them to, without being clear about what they want to achieve.
The employee may see it as a valuable opportunity to demonstrate their contribution, gain visibility or ask questions they cannot easily raise elsewhere. They may also use it to air frustrations about their manager or attempt to influence a decision from above.
Meanwhile, the manager in the middle may view the conversation as a healthy part of organisational life, or worry that their leadership is being assessed.
None of these motives is automatically wrong. The risk arises when they remain unspoken. When the purpose is unclear, people fill the gap with their own assumptions and agendas.
That’s why the senior leader needs to establish a clear starting point. This does not mean scripting every moment or preventing other useful issues from emerging. It does mean giving everyone a shared understanding of why the meeting is happening and what it’s intended to achieve.
Before sending the invitation, decide on its primary purpose. For example:
- Context: To explain direction, decisions or the wider organisational picture.
- Development: To discuss career aspirations, capabilities and future opportunities.
- Connection: To establish a relationship and better understand the person and their work.
- Sensing: To understand how strategy, priorities or change are being experienced closer to the work.
A conversation may move across more than one of these areas. However, naming its primary purpose creates useful boundaries, helps the employee prepare and reassures the manager that the meeting is not a covert assessment of their leadership.
Set expectations early
State the purpose in the invitation and reinforce it when the conversation begins. For example: “Today is about your development: understanding where you want to grow, what experience would help and how I can support your next step. It is not a performance discussion or an assessment of your manager”.
Keep the manager informed
The manager in the middle should know the conversation is happening and understand its purpose. Hearing about a skip-level meeting second-hand creates avoidable suspicion before the conversation has even begun.
Do your homework
Understand what the employee works on, what they have contributed and the pressures their area is facing. You do not need an exhaustive briefing, but you should know enough to ask informed questions. Turning up unprepared signals that the conversation matters less to you than it may to them.
Consider how you will handle what you hear
Think ahead about what information may need to be acted on, shared or kept private. Deciding this during the conversation and once the issue has surfaced increases the risk of you making promises you can’t keep.
During the conversation
Once the meeting begins, the objective is to create a useful, two-way exchange in which the employee can speak openly, gain perspective and leave with greater clarity.
That means paying attention not only to what you ask, but also to how you listen, respond and follow through.
Ask about the work and its context
Consider questions such as:
- What is working?
- Where are decisions slowing down?
- What is becoming harder?
- What information or clarity would help?
Avoid fishing for views about the manager
Questions such as “How are you finding your boss?” can place the employee in an unnecessarily difficult position. Ask about the work and the system unless there is a legitimate reason to discuss the management relationship.
Give something as well as gathering something
Share context, explain the reasoning behind a decision or offer a perspective the employee would not ordinarily have. Without some reciprocity, the meeting can feel like a one-way conversation focused on information extraction.
Do not dominate the conversation
The employee may be interested in your career journey and perspective, but do not let your own stories take over. Spending most of the meeting talking about yourself signals that the conversation is more about your need to be heard than their opportunity to be understood.
Explain what will happen with the information
Do not promise absolute confidentiality. There may be circumstances involving misconduct, safety or serious organisational risk where action is required. Be clear about those limits and, wherever possible, discuss with the employee how an issue will be handled.
After the conversation
Close the loop
When you agree to follow up on something, make a connection or provide information, follow through. If you take no action and the employee hears nothing further, they are unlikely to raise something important with you again.
Act transparently
Where an issue needs to be discussed with the employee’s manager, do so with the employee’s knowledge rather than taking it behind them.
Look for patterns
One conversation provides a perspective. Similar themes emerging across several conversations may point to an issue that warrants closer attention.
The Employee’s Preparation
People respond differently to the prospect of a skip-level meeting. Some will see it as a welcome opportunity to build visibility and gain perspective. Others may feel nervous, unsure what’s expected or concerned about saying the wrong thing.
Both reactions are understandable.
Regardless of how you view the conversation, it’s important to recognise that the meeting isn’t something that merely happens to you. No matter where you sit in the organisational hierarchy, you play a role in shaping whether the meeting becomes a useful conversation.
Before the conversation
Clarify the purpose
If the reason for the meeting is unclear, ask. Knowing whether the focus is development, connection, context, or sensing will help you prepare appropriately.
Decide what you want from the conversation
You may be seeking advice, broader context, greater visibility, a useful connection or a different perspective. Being clear about that will help you use the time well.
Prepare worthwhile questions
Bring a question that someone at that level is particularly well placed to answer. It might relate to future direction, how competing priorities are being balanced or which capabilities will matter most in the years ahead.
Prepare to explain your contribution
It is entirely reasonable to want the senior leader to understand the value you bring. Focus on contribution rather than activity. Connect your work to organisational priorities, the problems you are helping solve, the outcomes you are working towards and what you have learned.
Taking this approach will convey your value far more effectively than a list of tasks or a rehearsed sales pitch.
During the conversation
Be open, but considered
You don’t need to perform or have every answer. Speak honestly about your experience while remaining thoughtful about what you raise and how you frame it.
Focus on issues, not personalities
If you are raising a concern, describe what is happening, why it matters and what may help improve the situation. Avoid turning the conversation into a critique of your manager, team members or colleagues.
Research by Professor Ethan Burris found that managers reacted less positively when employees presented an issue as a direct challenge to the status quo. Even when the substance was similar, those employees were seen as less loyal and more threatening than employees who raised the issue while also signalling support for the organisation and a desire to improve it.3
That does not mean withholding legitimate concerns or disguising disagreement as support. It means separating the issue from the person, explaining its impact and offering a constructive path forward.
Use the opportunity to learn
Ask how the senior leader sees the organisation, the function or the challenges ahead. Their perspective may help you understand decisions, priorities and opportunities that are not visible from where you sit.
Avoid overstating your value
It is entirely reasonable to want the senior leader to understand your contribution. The strongest way to do that is to speak clearly about the work, its impact and what you have learned.
After the conversation
Follow through
The meeting is an opportunity for you to build trust and rapport with the senior leader, so do what you said you would do. A useful conversation becomes even more valuable based on what happens after the meeting.
Show appreciation
Thank the senior leader for their time and acknowledge anything that was particularly useful. A short follow-up email can reinforce the connection, especially when it refers to a specific insight or confirms what you will do next. Keep it genuine and concise.
Keep your manager appropriately informed
Where relevant, share the broad themes or actions from the meeting so it does not acquire an unnecessary sense of secrecy.
Reflect on what you learned
Consider what became clearer, what surprised you and what you will do differently as a result of the conversation.
Protection: Safeguard all Three Relationships
A skip-level meeting involves two people, but it affects three relationships.
The senior leader should not use the conversation to work around the manager. The employee should not use it as a shortcut around normal accountability. The manager should not interrogate the employee afterwards or attempt to control what is discussed beforehand.
That does not mean concerns about the manager can never be raised. There will be circumstances where speaking directly to the manager is unsafe, inappropriate or has already been attempted without success. Serious concerns about conduct, integrity, safety or wellbeing may also require a different organisational channel.
For ordinary work and relationship issues, however, the aim should be to strengthen the working relationship rather than create a competing one.
For the manager in the middle, an unexplained or secretive skip-level meeting can feel threatening. Senior leaders reduce that risk by being transparent about the purpose and making clear that the conversation is not a covert assessment of the manager’s competence.
Managers can help by treating skip-level contact as a normal part of a healthy organisation rather than a test of loyalty.
Making the Conversation Worth the Time
A skip-level meeting succeeds when its purpose is clear, both people prepare, something useful moves in each direction and the person outside the room remains part of a trusted system.
Before your next skip-level conversation, consider:
- What is the primary purpose, and do all three people understand it?
- What value am I prepared to contribute, rather than only take from the conversation?
- What follow-through will be needed, who will own it, and when will the loop be closed?
The meeting may last only 30 minutes or an hour, but its impact on trust can last far longer. Do the preparation, give the conversation your full attention and treat it with the care it deserves.
Getting you ready for tomorrow, today®
Award-winning author and global workplace expert, Dr Michelle Gibbings, helps leaders, teams and organisations unlock strategic influence to accelerate progress.
References:
- Seibert, S. E., Kraimer, M. L., & Liden, R. C. (2001). A social capital theory of career success. Academy of Management Journal, 44(2), 219–237. https://doi.org/10.5465/3069452
- Detert, J. R., & Treviño, L. K. (2010). Speaking up to higher-ups: How supervisors and skip-level leaders influence employee voice. Organization Science, 21(1), 249–270. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1080.0405
- Burris, E. R. (2012). The risks and rewards of speaking up: Managerial responses to employee voice. Academy of Management Journal, 55(4), 851–875. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2010.0562