Are You Getting the Best Thinking From Your Team? - Michelle Gibbings

[The Thinking in the Room: Article 1 of 3]

Imagine bringing your most capable people together to make an important decision. Between them, they have all the information needed to reach the right conclusion. Yet, collectively, you reach the wrong conclusion.

This is what psychologists Garold Stasser and William Titus uncovered in an experiment.¹

In the experiment, small groups were asked to select the best candidate for student body president. Each member received a different mix of facts about the three candidates. Some facts were known to everyone, while others were held by only one person.

When all the information was combined, one candidate should have emerged as the strongest choice. However, most groups failed to identify that candidate. Why?

It was because the discussions concentrated on information everyone already knew. While much of the information that was held by individual group members didn’t enter the conversation.

This finding has held up over time. A meta-analysis of 65 studies, involving 3,189 groups, found that groups spent more time discussing shared information than information held by individual members.²

Researchers describe this situation as a ‘hidden profile’. The information needed to identify the best answer or solution is distributed across group members, and the strongest choice only emerges when the different knowledge from those group members is combined.

In that meta-analysis, groups facing a hidden profile were eight times less likely to identify the correct solution than groups whose members had access to all the information.

Think about what this means for your leadership team. You can have the right expertise around the table and still make decisions that overlook what people know.

Having the Right People Isn’t Enough

Most leaders I work with understand the value of bringing different perspectives into a decision.

They assemble people with relevant expertise, encourage discussion and expect the combined knowledge to produce a better outcome. Yet having the right people in the room is only part of the equation.

Your team members and colleagues enter discussions with different information, experiences and assumptions. Some knowledge is widely shared, while other information sits with individuals who have direct exposure to particular issues.

When conversations move quickly towards agreement, familiar information can dominate. Additionally, people may assume that others already know what they know, or decide their contribution isn’t sufficiently relevant.

Even when someone raises a different perspective, the group may acknowledge it without examining its implications.

I’ve seen this happen many times. I remember working on a large project involving multiple teams, tight timeframes and competing priorities.

During a planning meeting, a team member raised concerns about a dependency that could affect our delivery schedule. We acknowledged the concern, but the conversation quickly moved on. The prevailing assumption was that the dependency was manageable, and no one stopped to test whether that was true.

Several weeks later, the issue resurfaced. The dependency was more complicated than we’d anticipated, and we had to revisit decisions and adjust the project timeline.

We had the information all along. Someone had raised the concern, and we heard what they said. Yet we hadn’t taken the time to properly understand what they knew or consider what it meant for our decision.

This is the leadership challenge: ensuring relevant information is surfaced, examined and used to inform the decision. It requires paying attention to how conversations unfold, whose knowledge is being considered and what happens to different perspectives once they’re shared.

Making Different Perspectives Count

The challenge becomes more complex when you consider the different backgrounds, experiences and expertise people bring to a team. Those differences provide opportunities for better decisions, provided people are willing to explore perspectives beyond their own.

Research by Professor Daan van Knippenberg and colleagues helps explain how teams benefit from diversity.³ Their work highlights the importance of exchanging, discussing and integrating different knowledge. When people engage seriously with perspectives that differ from their own, they have more information to draw upon. However, when those same differences create divisions, that exchange process can become harder.

More recent research takes this further. In a study published in October 2026, researcher Yongkang Yang, Professor Daan van Knippenberg and colleagues examined information exchange across more than one hundred culturally diverse project teams.⁴ They found that exchanges between culturally different team members were more strongly associated with team performance than exchanges between culturally similar members.

They also found that teams with a stronger learning orientation and a shared focus on development and improvement also engaged in more information exchange. Now, it’s worth noting that this study involved student project teams, so care is needed when applying the findings to a corporate workplace setting.

That said, it still raises a useful challenge: Are people in your team actively exploring different perspectives, or are they mainly exchanging information with those who think like them?

Build the Conditions for Collective Judgement

The research highlights how easily valuable information can be overlooked. As a leader, you can help to avoid this problem and elevate your team’s collective judgement with three practices: surface, sift and shape.

1. Surface What’s Unshared
The hidden profile research shows that information held by individuals can easily remain unshared. As a leader, you need to create opportunities for that knowledge to surface.

One way to do this is to ask team members, ahead of an important decision, to identify information they hold that others may not have considered. Ask them, ‘What do you know that the rest of us might not?’

Once you have gathered contributions independently, then give everyone an opportunity to share what they know before the discussion turns to preferred options.

This approach helps reveal information that might otherwise remain overlooked. It also reduces the risk of the first confident opinion shaping the discussion and influencing what others choose to share.

2. Sift Before You Settle
Once different information has surfaced, the next step is to examine it carefully.

When someone raises something the group hasn’t considered, take the time to explore it. Ask what evidence supports their perspective, how they reached that view and what it could mean for the decision.

Additionally, apply the same scrutiny to information the group already agrees on. Familiarity can create a sense of certainty, so examine the assumptions behind the facts and conclusions being presented.

Be particularly alert when agreement forms quickly. Before settling on a decision, ask: ‘What information haven’t we examined that could change our conclusion?’

Where decisions cross functional boundaries, bring the relevant people together to explore the implications. This helps the team identify connections, dependencies and risks that might otherwise be overlooked.

3. Shape the Decision Visibly
The final step is to bring the different perspectives and evidence together to shape the decision.

Consider what you’ve learned through the discussion, which information has challenged your initial thinking and how that should or could influence the outcome.

As you work towards a decision, be explicit about which information carries the greatest weight and why. Where there are competing perspectives, explain how you’ve weighed them and the reasoning behind your conclusion.

It’s equally important to acknowledge contributions that haven’t been adopted. People won’t always agree with the final decision, but understanding how their input was considered helps build confidence in the process.

Making your reasoning visible also gives others an opportunity to challenge your conclusions or identify gaps before the decision is finalised.

Start With One Question

So where do you start?

At your next decision meeting, change the order of the conversation. Before anyone states their preferred option, ask each person to share one relevant piece of information that others may not know.

Give people time to explain what they know and why it matters. You may discover that some of the most useful information was sitting in the room all along, waiting for someone to ask.

This is the first article in The Thinking in the Room series. Next week, I’ll explore how seniority can change the information reaching you, often without you realising it.

Getting you ready for tomorrow, today®

Award-winning author and global workplace expert, Dr Michelle Gibbings, helps leaders, teams and organisations unlock strategic influence to accelerate progress.

References:

  1. Stasser, G., and Titus, W. (1985). Pooling of unshared information in group decision making: Biased information sampling during discussion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48(6), 1467–1478. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467
  2. Lu, L., Yuan, Y. C., and McLeod, P. L. (2012). Twenty-five years of hidden profiles in group decision making: A meta-analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(1), 54–75. https://doi.org/10.1177/1088868311417243
  3. van Knippenberg, D., De Dreu, C. K. W., and Homan, A. C. (2004). Work group diversity and group performance: An integrative model and research agenda. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(6), 1008–1022. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.89.6.1008
  4. Yang, Y., van Knippenberg, D., Nederveen Pieterse, A., and Li, J. (2026). With whom you elaborate matters: How learning orientation impacts cross-culture and same-culture information elaboration in culturally diverse teams. Journal of Business and Psychology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10869-026-10161-9

 



Publication: | | | |