
[The Thinking in the Room: Article 2 of 3]
Some years ago, I needed to speak with a senior executive I’d worked with previously. I rang his office expecting his executive assistant to answer, but instead, he did. When I expressed surprise, he said, ‘I don’t want a gatekeeper controlling what I hear and see.’
He understood that as you become more senior, more people influence what reaches you, and that means what you hear and see is often selected, summarised, softened and shaped before you see it. Every layer of management in your organisation creates another opportunity for this to happen.
Last week, in Are You Getting the Best Thinking From Your Team, I explored how valuable information can be overlooked in team discussions. This week, the focus shifts to what happens as information travels upward, and why senior leaders can have an incomplete picture of what’s really going on.
Why People Hold Back
Some information gets filtered as it moves through an organisation, while other information never makes it into the conversation because people decide it’s better left unsaid. They may worry about how their message will be received, whether raising an issue will damage relationships, or whether anything will change as a result.
Research by Professor Frances Milliken and colleagues explored why employees sometimes choose to remain silent, even when they believe their concerns are important.¹
In their study, 85 per cent of participants reported having been in situations where they felt unable to raise an important issue with their supervisor. These weren’t necessarily minor concerns. They included problems with processes and performance, opportunities for improvement and questions about the competence of colleagues and managers.
The most common reason for holding back was fear of being viewed negatively or damaging relationships they valued. People weighed up the potential consequences of speaking up and what it might mean for them. Interestingly, that reluctance was often shared. Employees who felt uncomfortable raising an issue frequently believed their colleagues felt the same way.
When several people recognise the same problem but none feels comfortable raising it, leaders can remain unaware of issues that others already know about.
While fear of the consequences is one reason people stay quiet, another is the belief that speaking up won’t make any difference.
Earlier research by Professors Elizabeth Wolfe Morrison and Frances Milliken explored how employees can come to believe that raising concerns is pointless, particularly when previous attempts to speak up have achieved little.²
These two beliefs can reinforce each other. If raising an issue feels risky and unlikely to change anything, people have little incentive to speak up. And when enough people reach that conclusion, silence can become an accepted part of how the organisation operates.
Why Seniority Amplifies the Problem
You might assume that people’s willingness to speak up depends largely on their relationship with their immediate manager.
However, research by Professors James Detert and Linda Treviño suggests that the influence extends much further.³ They conducted interviews with employees at different levels of a multinational company. Participants identified leaders two to five levels above them as reasons speaking up felt risky or futile. These senior leaders were mentioned almost as frequently as the immediate managers.
Some of that influence came through direct interactions. However, employees also formed views about senior leaders based on their reputation, decisions, and how they behaved towards others.
Think about how this plays out in your organisation and team. Your team members and colleagues don’t always need to interact with you directly to form an opinion about how approachable you are or how you might respond to unwelcome news.
They watch what happens when someone challenges a decision, raises a concern or questions an established way of working. Those observations influence what they feel comfortable saying and what they decide to keep to themselves.
The more senior you become, the further that influence can extend. At the same time, the more removed you are from day-to-day operations, the harder it can be to recognise what people aren’t sharing with you.
Silence Tells You Very Little
Here’s where it gets tricky.
When the people around you aren’t raising concerns, how do you know whether everything is going well or whether they’ve simply decided it’s easier to stay quiet?
You might be receiving regular updates, hearing consistent messages from different people and feeling reasonably confident that you understand what’s happening. However, the information reaching you may have passed through several layers, and so, along the way, details can be lost or altered, concerns softened and massaged, and assumptions repeated until they start to sound like facts.
And when everyone seems to be telling you the same thing, it’s easy to assume you’re getting the full picture.
Of course, you don’t want to become suspicious of every report or start questioning everything people tell you. Instead, you want to bring a healthy dose of scepticism and curiosity to what you’re hearing. Consider where the information comes from, whose perspectives are represented, and what might be missing. Remember, some of the people with the most valuable insights may be the very people who are least comfortable sharing them with you.
Make It Safe, Make It Count, Make It Normal
In my work with senior leaders, I often see a gap between how approachable they believe they are and how approachable others find them.
It’s a useful reminder that our intentions and how others experience us don’t always align. We might think we’re encouraging people to speak openly, while they remain cautious about what they’re willing to share.
So, it’s worth asking someone you trust how you come across when people challenge you or raise concerns. Alternatively, this is where engaging in a 360-degree feedback process is helpful. Through both processes, you’ll likely discover something about your reactions that you hadn’t recognised.
From there, consider what you can do to make it easier for people to share what they know, particularly when the information is uncomfortable or challenges an established view. Three practices can help: make it safe, make it count and make it normal.
1. Make It Safe
Fear is personal, so your first task is to reduce the perceived risk of raising an issue with you.
Start with the questions you ask. ‘Any concerns?’ is easy to answer with a polite no. More specific questions invite people to share what they’re experiencing. For example, ‘What’s slowing this project down?’ or ‘Where are we most likely to be caught out?’ or ‘What assumptions are underpinning our analysis?’
As well, pay attention to the setting. Some of your team members may not feel comfortable raising an issue in a large meeting, and be more comfortable doing so one-to-one or in a smaller group.
When someone raises a concern, pay attention to your immediate response. Acknowledge what they’ve said, ask questions to understand their perspective and resist the urge to defend your position. Your team will notice your immediate reaction, particularly when it challenges your position, ego and established view.
2. Make It Count
Think about what happens when someone raises an issue, makes a suggestion or shares a concern, and then hears nothing more about it. They might raise it again, but if the same thing keeps happening, they’ll eventually question whether speaking up is worth the effort.
That’s why following through matters. When people take the time to share their views, let them know what’s happened as a result.
You won’t always be able to act on what they’ve raised, and that’s fine. What matters is explaining what you’ve considered, what you’ve decided and why. And when something does change, be specific about it.
For example, rather than simply saying, ‘Thanks for the feedback’, you could say, ‘You raised concerns about the approval delays, so we’ve reviewed the process and removed one sign-off step.’
When your team members understand how their input has been considered, they’re more likely to feel that speaking up is worthwhile, even when the final decision isn’t what they’d hoped for.
3. Make It Normal
The more unusual it is for people to talk with you, the more significant the interaction can feel. And when conversations feel high stakes, people are more likely to be careful about what they say.
That’s why it’s worth making regular contact with people across different levels of your organisation part of your day-to-day leadership.
As well, how you approach these conversations matters. If every discussion with you feels like a performance update or mini-interrogation, you’ll probably only hear what people think you want to hear.
So, take an interest in their work and what they’re experiencing. For example, ask what’s making their job harder than it needs to be, where decisions are getting stuck, what’s working well for them, where they’d like greater involvement or what they wish you’d better understood.
You don’t need to make this process overly complicated. A short monthly conversation with a different team member, or occasionally joining a team meeting to listen, can help you build a more complete picture over time.
Be mindful, too, of existing reporting relationships. These conversations should strengthen your understanding of what’s happening across the organisation, without creating a parallel reporting line.
As you have these conversations, pay attention to how what you’re hearing compares with the updates and reports you usually receive. Are people describing the same challenges and priorities, or are you hearing a different version of what’s happening?
Where there are differences, take the time to explore them. Ask what’s behind the different perspectives and whether important details or concerns have been lost along the way. You may discover that some of the information you’ve been relying on is incomplete, or that assumptions have been accepted without being properly tested.
Start With One Conversation
This week, seek out someone whose perspective you don’t regularly hear. It might be someone in another team, a colleague closer to the frontline or someone working in a different part of your organisation.
Ask them: ‘What do you wish I understood about the work you do?’ Then, give them time to think and respond. Listen with curiosity, particularly if what they share surprises you or challenges what you’ve previously been told.
You don’t need to have all the answers or immediately offer a solution. What matters is taking a genuine interest in what they have to say and being willing to reconsider what you thought you knew.
And if something needs following up, make sure you do. How you respond to this conversation will influence what they’re willing to share with you next time.
This is the second article in The Thinking in the Room series. Next week, I’ll explore what happens when information does reach you, and whether you’re prepared to let it change your mind.
Getting you ready for tomorrow, today®
Award-winning author and global workplace expert, Dr Michelle Gibbings, helps leaders, teams and organisations unlock strategic influence to accelerate progress.
References:
- Milliken, F. J., Morrison, E. W., and Hewlin, P. F. (2003). An exploratory study of employee silence: Issues that employees don’t communicate upward and why. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6), 1453–1476. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6486.00387
- Morrison, E. W., and Milliken, F. J. (2000). Organizational silence: A barrier to change and development in a pluralistic world. Academy of Management Review, 25(4), 706–725. https://doi.org/10.2307/259200
- Detert, J. R., and Treviño, L. K. (2010). Speaking up to higher-ups: How supervisors and skip-level leaders influence employee voice. Organization Science, 21(1), 249–270. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1080.0405